Chapters0/26 ▾
Chapter 1 · Lesson 2 of 4
Locating engine noises
1 min read
ASE noise questions are solved by asking what changes the noise. A sound caused by combustion pressure changes when you take that pressure away, a sound caused by oil supply changes with oil pressure, and a sound caused by a part that is loaded only in gear appears only in gear.
- Rod bearing knock: a heavy knock, loudest under acceleration, that gets noticeably quieter when the ignition to that cylinder is disabled, because the firing pulse is what drives the loose rod into its journal.
- Lifter tap on cold start: a light rapping from the top of the engine that fades within seconds and returns only after the vehicle sits overnight. Oil drained out of the lifters, often past a failed anti-drainback valve in the filter.
- Knock only in gear: a knock heard in DRIVE with the brakes applied but gone in PARK and NEUTRAL at the same rpm points to a cracked flexplate or a failing torque converter, since only those parts are loaded in gear.
Example: a knock is loud at 2,000 rpm under load. You unplug the coil on each cylinder in turn, and the knock softens only when cylinder 2 is disabled. That points to the cylinder 2 rod bearing. A collapsed lifter or a loose damper would sound the same no matter which cylinder you shut off.
Check yourself
1. On the first start of the day an engine makes a light rapping from the top of the engine that fades after a few seconds and does not return until the next morning. What is the most likely cause?
2. An engine has a heavy knock that is loudest under acceleration. When the ignition to number four cylinder is disabled, the knock becomes noticeably quieter. Which component is the most likely source?
Facts checked 2026-11-15 · Sources: ASE: Official Automobile Study Guide (A1 Engine Repair test specifications and task list), ASE: Automobile and Light Truck (A1-A9) tests
ASE Automotive Technician cheat sheet: every key fact on one page →