Chapters0/35 ▾
Chapter 1 · Lesson 4 of 5
Evaluating arguments and evidence
1 min read
Editorials, letters and speeches make claims, and HiSET asks whether the support holds up. First list the writer's reasons. Then check each piece of evidence against them: relevant evidence backs a specific reason, while irrelevant evidence, such as a personal story about one family, supports none of them and says nothing about the larger group.
- Hasty generalization: one incident becomes a claim about everyone. A writer who saw one late bus and calls the whole transit system unreliable is generalizing from a single case.
- Fact versus opinion: a fact can be checked, such as the number of buses on a route, while an opinion is a judgment, such as calling the route a waste of money. A strong argument backs its opinions with checkable facts.
- Ignoring the data: a strong argument answers the larger body of evidence instead of brushing it aside.
- Data in tables: when a claim depends on a comparison, find the two numbers that make it. If a new evening clinic added 40 visits while daytime visits fell by only 5, most evening patients are new rather than moved from the day.
Check yourself
1. Read the passage and answer the question. On her first week at the Blue Plate, June dropped two plates, mixed up a table's orders, and once poured decaf for a man who had asked, very clearly, for regular. Every mistake seemed to end at the pass-through window, where Mr. Okafor, the cook, stood with his arms folded and said nothing. She was sure he was keeping a list. On Friday the manager called her into the office, and June walked back past the grill already composing what she would tell her mother. Instead, the manager said the morning crew wanted her kept on and asked whether she could take Saturdays. When she came out, Mr. Okafor was scraping the grill. Taped above the order rail, where it had not been on Monday, was an index card in thick black marker: TABLE NUMBERS — LEFT TO RIGHT — 1 TO 12. It was placed exactly at June's eye level, a good foot below where anyone else would have needed it. Which detail from the passage best supports the inference that Mr. Okafor was quietly trying to help June succeed?
2. Read the passage and answer the question. Mr. Ferreira had driven a city bus for thirty-one years, and in retirement he could not stand to see anything with wheels sit broken. When the boy from 4B left his bicycle chained to the stair rail with a bent rim and a slipped chain, Mr. Ferreira waited three days, then knocked on the door with a toolbox. He did not fix the bicycle. He sat on an overturned bucket and told the boy which wrench to use, and when the boy used the wrong one anyway, he said, “Now you know what that one is for,” and waited again. It took the whole of a Saturday. In June, Mr. Ferreira moved to his daughter's house in Sacramento. In August, a girl on the second floor flattened her front tire on the curb outside the building. The boy from 4B came downstairs with a patch kit and an overturned bucket, sat down beside her, and pointed at the tire levers. “Not that one,” he said. “Try the other.” Which statement best expresses a theme of the passage?
3. Read the passage and answer the question. The following passage is from a letter to the editor. Last Thursday, as I walked out of the post office on Main Street, a teenager on a rented electric scooter swerved onto the sidewalk and nearly knocked me down. He did not stop or apologize. That moment told me everything I need to know about the scooter program the city began this summer. The riders are reckless, the scooters are a menace, and the program should end before someone is seriously hurt. The city points to its own figures: more than 40,000 rides since June, with three reported injuries, none of them serious. But numbers on a spreadsheet cannot compete with what I saw with my own eyes. I have lived in this town for thirty-one years, and I know what is safe on its sidewalks and what is not. I urge the council to cancel the scooter contract at its next meeting. Which statement best describes a weakness in the writer's reasoning?
Facts checked 2026-11-15 · Sources: HiSET Test at a Glance (TAAG): Language Arts – Reading
HiSET cheat sheet: every key fact on one page →