25 Logical Reasoning: Assumptions & Flaws Practice Questions & Answers
Every Logical Reasoning: Assumptions & Flaws practice question from the Foreign Service Officer Test (FSOT) Practice Test, with the correct answer and a short explanation.
Start practice test →1. The cultural affairs office at a hypothetical embassy surveyed people who attended its free jazz concert series. Eighty percent of the attendees who answered said they viewed the United States favorably, compared with 50 percent in a recent nationwide poll of the host country. The cultural affairs officer concludes that the concert series made attendees view the United States more favorably and asks for funds to double the number of concerts. Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?
- A.Jazz is more effective than any other musical genre at improving how audiences view the United States
- B.Doubling the number of concerts would cost less than expanding any other program the office runs
- C.Every single person who attended a concert in the series also completed the office's follow-up survey
- D.Before attending, the concertgoers did not already view the United States far more favorably than average✓ Answer
The argument infers a causal effect from a difference between attendees and the general public, so it must assume the difference did not exist before the concerts. Negate it (attendees were already far more favorable) and the survey gap no longer shows any effect. A complete response rate, the superiority of jazz over every genre and the relative cost of expansion are stronger or unrelated claims the argument does not need.
Ref QB-SR6GFUSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.5 Informal Fallacies: biased sample and false causeReport a problem with this question
2. The general services officer at a hypothetical embassy proposes replacing the motor pool's gasoline sedans with hybrid vehicles. Hybrids of the model under consideration use 40 percent less fuel per kilometer than the current sedans. The officer concludes that after the switch the motor pool will consume less fuel each year than it does now. Which one of the following is an assumption required by the argument?
- A.Fuel prices in the host country will not rise during the years the hybrids are in service
- B.Drivers in the motor pool will prefer the hybrids to the sedans they currently drive
- C.The motor pool will not drive so many more kilometers that its total fuel use goes up✓ Answer
- D.The hybrids will cost no more to purchase and maintain than the sedans they replace
Total fuel use equals fuel per kilometer times kilometers driven, so a lower rate cuts the total only if distance does not grow enough to offset it. Negating that assumption (the pool drives far more) makes the conclusion false. The conclusion is about the amount of fuel, not spending, so fuel prices and purchase costs are out of scope, and driver preference does not affect consumption.
Ref QB-B9QY7WSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.4 Types of Inferences: inductive and abductive inference and competing explanationsReport a problem with this question
3. Under a hypothetical embassy's staffing rules, every officer who supervises locally employed staff has completed the post's leadership seminar. Officer Reyes supervises three locally employed staff members in the economic section. The management counselor therefore concludes that Officer Reyes may apply to serve as acting deputy chief of mission. The conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
- A.Only officers who supervise locally employed staff may apply to serve as acting deputy
- B.Any officer who has completed the leadership seminar may apply to serve as acting deputy✓ Answer
- C.No officer who has skipped the leadership seminar may apply to serve as the acting deputy
- D.Any officer who may apply to serve as acting deputy has completed the leadership seminar
The premises give a chain: Reyes supervises local staff, so Reyes completed the seminar. To reach eligibility, completing the seminar must be sufficient for eligibility, which is what 'any officer who has completed the seminar may apply' says. The reversed conditional, the 'only' statement and the 'no officer who skipped' statement each make a condition necessary for eligibility, and a necessary condition never guarantees that someone qualifies.
Ref QB-TRHTMVSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.2 Logical Statements: necessary and sufficient conditions in conditionals and universal statementsReport a problem with this question
4. A hypothetical embassy's public affairs section reviews grant proposals from local organizations. Its guidelines say the section funds only proposals that include a plan for measuring results. The Riverside Youth Forum submitted its proposal before the deadline, and the proposal includes a detailed plan for measuring results. The grants officer concludes that the section will fund the Riverside proposal. The conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
- A.Most on-time proposals with measurement plans have been funded by the section in past years
- B.The Riverside Youth Forum has received grants from the section in several earlier years
- C.The section funds every on-time proposal that includes a plan for measuring results✓ Answer
- D.The section funds only proposals that arrive before the deadline set in its guidelines
The guideline makes a measurement plan necessary ('funds only proposals that include'), which cannot guarantee funding. Adding a rule that every on-time proposal with a plan is funded makes those features sufficient, so the conclusion is then guaranteed. Another 'only' rule adds a second necessary condition, a 'most' pattern only makes funding likely, and past grants to the same group do not settle this proposal.
Ref QB-89NYPSSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.2 Logical Statements: necessary and sufficient conditions in conditionals and universal statementsReport a problem with this question
5. A hypothetical embassy's security rules state that anyone inside the chancery without a building pass must be escorted at all times. This week, contract technicians are repairing the chancery's air-conditioning system, and none of them has a building pass. The post security officer concludes that each technician must be logged in the visitor register. The conclusion follows logically if which one of the following is assumed?
- A.Everyone who is logged in the visitor register must be escorted while in the chancery
- B.Contract technicians are usually logged in the visitor register when they work at the chancery
- C.Everyone who must be escorted in the chancery must be logged in the visitor register✓ Answer
- D.Some people who must be escorted in the chancery are also logged in the visitor register
The premises establish that each technician must be escorted; the conclusion introduces a new term, the visitor register. A bridge from 'must be escorted' to 'must be logged' completes a valid chain. The reversed conditional runs from register to escort and proves nothing about the technicians, while 'some' and 'usually' statements cannot guarantee that every technician must be logged.
Ref QB-QRFT4SSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.2 Logical Statements: necessary and sufficient conditions in conditionals and universal statementsReport a problem with this question
6. After the consular section of a hypothetical embassy posted a short video explaining which documents visa applicants must bring, the share of interviews postponed because of missing documents fell from 20 percent to 8 percent over the next three months. The consular chief concludes that the video caused the decline. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
- A.At two similar posts that posted no such video, postponements for missing documents did not fall✓ Answer
- B.Postponements for missing documents had been falling steadily for a year before the video
- C.The video was viewed more times in its first month than any earlier video the embassy had ever posted
- D.Applicants surveyed at the post said they generally prefer video instructions to written ones
A comparison group strengthens a causal claim by showing the effect is absent where the cause is absent: similar posts without the video saw no decline, which makes a region-wide alternative cause less likely. View counts and stated preferences do not show that the video changed behavior, and a decline already under way before the video is an alternative explanation that weakens the argument.
Ref QB-99ZAVTSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.5 Informal Fallacies: false cause (correlation does not equal causation)Report a problem with this question
7. After the human resources unit at a hypothetical embassy began allowing two telework days a week, the unit processed 30 percent more personnel actions per month than in the previous year. The management officer argues that telework raised the unit's productivity and recommends offering it to the financial management unit as well. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument that telework raised the unit's productivity?
- A.Staff in the financial management unit have said they would welcome two telework days a week
- B.Several other embassies in the region adopted similar telework policies during the same year
- C.The unit's staffing, software and procedures stayed the same across both of the years compared✓ Answer
- D.Employees in the human resources unit reported higher job satisfaction after telework began
The argument moves from a before-and-after increase to a causal claim, so it is strengthened by ruling out other changes that could explain the increase, such as new staff or new software. Enthusiasm in another unit concerns the recommendation, not the causal claim; job satisfaction is not output; and other embassies' policies say nothing about this unit's results.
Ref QB-RRT5ATSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.5 Informal Fallacies: false causeReport a problem with this question
8. A hypothetical embassy's survey found that alumni of its young-leaders exchange program are twice as likely as other young professionals in the host country to hold leadership roles in local civic groups. The cultural affairs officer concludes that the exchange program builds participants' leadership skills. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
- A.Many alumni described the program in interviews as the most valuable experience of their careers
- B.The program accepts only applicants who already lead student or civic organizations at home
- C.Before the exchange, alumni held civic leadership roles at the same rate as applicants not chosen✓ Answer
- D.The number of civic groups in the host country has grown steadily over the past decade
The main rival explanation is selection: the program may simply pick people who were already leaders. Showing that alumni and rejected applicants led civic groups at the same rate before the exchange rules out that rival, so the later gap points to the program. Testimonials are not evidence of an effect, an only-leaders admission rule supports the selection explanation and weakens the argument, and growth in civic groups affects everyone equally.
Ref QB-E9SYQZSource: Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Fallacies: Unrepresentative Sample and False CauseReport a problem with this question
9. Since the consular section of a hypothetical embassy began requiring original bank statements instead of photocopies, the number of forged financial documents its officers detect each month has fallen by half, while the number of applications has stayed about the same. The fraud prevention manager concludes that the new requirement has deterred applicants from submitting forged documents. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
- A.Random re-checks of approved cases found fewer undetected forgeries than before the change✓ Answer
- B.Applicants have complained that local banks take several weeks to issue original statements
- C.Most applicants at the post submit statements from one of three large local banks in the city
- D.Officers say that original statements take longer to examine closely than photocopies did
A drop in detections could mean fewer forgeries or simply that officers now miss more of them. Random re-checks showing fewer undetected forgeries rule out the 'missed forgeries' explanation, so the drop more likely reflects deterrence. Bank delays are an unrelated cost, slower examination of originals suggests detection got harder and weakens the argument, and the source banks are irrelevant.
Ref QB-WRKT5ZSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.4 Types of Inferences: inductive and abductive inference and competing explanationsReport a problem with this question
10. Before a new round of hypothetical trade talks, the head of a U.S. delegation argues that offering a small concession at the opening session will lead the other side to offer one in return. She points out that in each of the last three rounds with this counterpart, an early concession by her delegation was matched by the other side within a day. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
- A.The other side's entire negotiating team has been replaced after the last round of talks ended
- B.In earlier rounds, when the delegation made no early concession, the other side made none either✓ Answer
- C.The counterpart's new chief negotiator has publicly praised the delegation's professionalism
- D.Both delegations have agreed to hold this round of talks in a neutral third country this year
Three cases in which a concession was followed by a concession could be coincidence; showing that the other side did not concede when no early concession was made supports the causal link, because the effect disappears when the cause is absent. A replaced team weakens the prediction, praise for professionalism is diplomatically appealing but says nothing about reciprocity, and the venue is irrelevant.
Ref QB-EJHTFESource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.4 Types of Inferences: inductive and abductive inference and competing explanationsReport a problem with this question
11. About 15 percent of applicants miss their scheduled visa interviews at a hypothetical embassy, leaving interview slots unused. To cut the no-show rate, the consular section plans to send every applicant a text-message reminder 48 hours before the interview. Which, if true, would most undermine the strategy?
- A.Records show that most applicants who miss interviews had canceled their trips, not forgotten✓ Answer
- B.Some applicants change their mobile phone numbers between booking and the interview date
- C.Sending the text reminders would add a modest monthly cost to the consular section's budget
- D.A neighboring post cut its no-show rate by about a third last year by sending text reminders
A reminder can only fix absences caused by forgetting. If most no-shows come from people who canceled their travel, the plan does not reach the main cause and fails its own stated aim. A modest cost and a few changed phone numbers are minor drawbacks that leave the plan largely effective, and a neighboring post's success supports the plan.
Ref QB-X2QY2FSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.4 Types of Inferences: inductive and abductive inference and competing explanationsReport a problem with this question
12. In the six months after a hypothetical embassy began writing its social media posts in the host country's language instead of English, its account gained 60 percent more followers. The public affairs officer concludes that posts in the local language reach more of the host country's public than English posts do. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?
- A.The platform's follower count may include a small number of inactive or duplicate accounts
- B.English is widely understood among university students, a group the embassy often tries to reach
- C.A few of the local-language posts contained small translation errors that readers pointed out
- D.During the same six months, the embassy also paid to advertise its account on local television✓ Answer
The argument credits the language change for growth that followed it. A television advertising campaign in the same period is an alternative cause that could explain the growth without any effect from language. Minor translation errors do not explain the growth, a few inactive accounts barely touch a 60 percent rise and attack a premise's precision rather than the reasoning, and English use among students does not show the local-language posts reached fewer people.
Ref QB-FJV5NFSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.5 Informal Fallacies: false causeReport a problem with this question
13. To reduce the electricity costs of a hypothetical embassy's chancery, the facility manager plans to set all office thermostats two degrees warmer during the summer months. Engineers estimate that the change would cut the air-conditioning system's power use by about 10 percent. Which, if true, would most undermine the strategy?
- A.Several staff members say warmer offices would make summer afternoons less comfortable
- B.Other embassies in the same city keep their summer thermostats at the cooler setting
- C.The air-conditioning system is due for routine servicing in the middle of the summer
- D.The chancery lease charges the embassy a fixed electricity fee however much power it uses✓ Answer
The plan's stated goal is lower electricity costs, not lower power use. If the lease sets a fixed fee regardless of consumption, saving power saves no money, so the plan cannot achieve its aim. Staff discomfort is a minor side effect, other embassies' settings are irrelevant, and routine servicing does not affect whether the change lowers costs.
Ref QB-Y23B8GSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.4 Types of Inferences: inductive and abductive inference and competing explanationsReport a problem with this question
14. At a hypothetical embassy, visa applicants who submitted the new online application form last year had a refusal rate of 5 percent, compared with 25 percent for applicants who used the paper form. The consular chief concludes that requiring all applicants to use the online form will substantially lower the post's refusal rate. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?
- A.The online form asks exactly the same questions as the paper form, in the very same order
- B.Some applicants in rural areas lack reliable internet access and would have to use a kiosk
- C.Officers need about twice as long to review a paper form as they need for an online form
- D.Last year the online form was limited to applicants renewing a visa they had held before✓ Answer
The comparison is valid only if the two groups were alike. If online users were all renewal applicants, who already qualified for a visa once, their low refusal rate reflects who they were, not the form, so moving everyone online need not lower refusals. Review time and rural access are side issues, and identical questions make the form itself even less likely to explain the gap.
Ref QB-CJT55CSource: Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Fallacies: Unrepresentative SampleReport a problem with this question
15. At a hypothetical embassy, the staff members who attended the most training courses last year also received the highest performance ratings. The management officer concludes that training improves job performance and plans to require every employee to take at least three courses a year. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?
- A.Supervisors at the post approve training requests mainly for staff they already rate highly✓ Answer
- B.The post's performance ratings use the same written standards as those used at other posts
- C.Training courses take staff members away from their regular duties for several days each year
- D.Some of the post's training courses are offered online, while others are held in person
The argument reads a correlation as training causing performance. If supervisors mostly approve training for people they already rate highly, the causation may run the other way: high ratings lead to more training. Time away from duties is a cost of the plan, not a challenge to the causal claim; the course format is irrelevant; and shared rating standards do not explain the correlation.
Ref QB-V2ZAQCSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.5 Informal Fallacies: false cause (correlation does not equal causation)Report a problem with this question
16. The new deputy consular chief at a hypothetical embassy read every public complaint the section received during her first week. All three complaints concerned the section's telephone information line. She concludes that the telephone line is the main source of public complaints about the consular section throughout the year and should be the top priority for improvement. The reasoning is flawed because it
- A.treats the timing of the complaints after a phone-line change as proof the change caused them
- B.dismisses the complaints by questioning the motives of the people who submitted them
- C.treats a condition needed to improve the phone line as if it would guarantee an improvement
- D.draws a conclusion about a whole year from a few complaints received in one single week✓ Answer
Three complaints from a single week are far too little evidence for a claim about the whole year; that is a hasty generalization. The passage mentions no change to the phone line, so there is no timing-as-cause error; the deputy does not attack the complainants; and no necessary or sufficient condition for improvement is discussed.
Ref QB-DJ6GADSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.5 Informal Fallacies: hasty generalizationReport a problem with this question
17. A press officer at a hypothetical embassy reviewed three years of records and found that the months in which the embassy hosted the most cultural events were also the months with the most favorable local press coverage of the embassy. She concludes that hosting cultural events causes favorable coverage and proposes doubling the events calendar. The reasoning is flawed because it
- A.overlooks the chance that some other factor raised both the number of events and the coverage✓ Answer
- B.rejects a rival explanation merely on the ground that no one has produced evidence for it
- C.uses the word 'favorable' in one sense in the evidence and in a different sense in the conclusion
- D.relies on too few months of records to reveal any pattern in the embassy's press coverage
Two things rising together does not show that one causes the other: a third factor, such as a national holiday season or a high-profile visit, could bring both more events and warmer coverage. Thirty-six months of records is not a tiny sample, the officer never rejects a rival explanation, and 'favorable' is used in the same sense throughout.
Ref QB-W2CNVDSource: Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Fallacies: Common Cause and Cum Hoc, Ergo Propter HocReport a problem with this question
18. Under a hypothetical embassy's rules, an officer must pass the advanced language exam in order to be assigned to the economic section. Officer Chen passed the advanced language exam last month. The assistant to the deputy chief of mission therefore tells colleagues that Officer Chen will be assigned to the economic section. The reasoning is flawed because it
- A.generalizes about every officer at the post from the experience of one single officer
- B.treats a condition that is enough for the assignment as though it were required for it
- C.treats a requirement for the assignment as though meeting it were enough to secure it✓ Answer
- D.relies on the assistant's position rather than on evidence about how assignments are made
'Must pass the exam in order to be assigned' makes passing a necessary condition: assigned only if passed. Concluding assignment from passing treats that necessary condition as sufficient (affirming the consequent). The reverse confusion is not committed, no generalization about all officers is made, and the assistant's rank plays no role in the reasoning.
Ref QB-AJ4GS9Source: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.4 Types of Inferences: valid forms (modus ponens, modus tollens) and the invalid form affirming the consequentReport a problem with this question
19. A hypothetical embassy's visitor policy exempts official visitors, meaning representatives of foreign governments, from bag screening at the entrance. A local journalist arriving for an interview told the guard that she was there on official business for her newspaper. The guard concluded that, under the policy, she was exempt from bag screening. The reasoning is flawed because it
- A.relies on the policy's popularity among staff rather than on what the policy actually says
- B.shifts the meaning of 'official' from the policy's sense to the journalist's everyday use✓ Answer
- C.presents only two screening options when other ways of checking visitors are available
- D.assumes the journalist cannot be trusted simply on account of her job at a local newspaper
The policy uses 'official' to mean a representative of a foreign government; the journalist uses it loosely to mean work-related. Treating the two senses as one is equivocation, and it is the only thing that lets the conclusion follow. The guard does not distrust the journalist, does not reduce the choice to two options and does not appeal to the policy's popularity.
Ref QB-T2ANCASource: Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Fallacies: EquivocationReport a problem with this question
20. A local nonprofit published a report arguing that a hypothetical embassy's small-grants process takes too long, citing an average of 140 days between application and award. The embassy's grants officer responded that the report can be dismissed, since the nonprofit itself was turned down for a grant last year and therefore has a reason to criticize the process. The reasoning is flawed because it
- A.concludes the process is fast simply from the report's failure to prove that it is slow
- B.rejects the report's claim by pointing to its author's motives rather than to its evidence✓ Answer
- C.assumes that a process which has been slow in the past must remain slow in the future
- D.takes for granted that the report's conclusion is true in the course of arguing for it
The 140-day figure is evidence that stands or falls on its own; a possible grudge does not make it false. Dismissing a claim because of the arguer's motives is a circumstantial ad hominem. The officer makes no prediction about the future, does not assume the report's conclusion, and never claims the process is fast.
Ref QB-9TJBAKSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.5 Informal Fallacies: ad hominem attacksReport a problem with this question
21. A commercial officer at a hypothetical embassy reasons as follows: If the embassy hosts a trade fair this month, visits to its business information center will rise. Visits to the business information center rose this month. So the embassy must have hosted a trade fair this month. Which one contains a pattern of flawed reasoning most similar to that in the commercial officer's argument?
- A.If a shipment clears customs, the warehouse logs it. The warehouse has not logged the shipment, so the shipment has not cleared customs
- B.If the ambassador travels to the capital, a motorcade is scheduled. A motorcade was scheduled today, so the ambassador must be traveling to the capital✓ Answer
- C.If the visa system goes offline, interviews are postponed. The system did not go offline today, so no interviews were postponed today
- D.Two of this summer's interns speak fluent French, so most of the interns the embassy hosts each summer must speak fluent French as well
The original has the form 'If A then B; B; so A', which affirms the consequent: visits could have risen for other reasons. The motorcade argument has the same form, since a motorcade could be scheduled for other trips. The visa-system argument denies the antecedent ('not A, so not B'), the customs argument is valid modus tollens ('not B, so not A'), and the interns argument is a hasty generalization with no conditional at all.
Ref QB-RAD6QJSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.4 Types of Inferences: valid forms (modus ponens, modus tollens) and the invalid form affirming the consequentReport a problem with this question
22. Of the visa applicants who wrote to a hypothetical embassy's consular inbox last month, 70 percent complained about the online appointment system. The consular chief concludes that most of the post's visa applicants are dissatisfied with the appointment system. Which one contains a pattern of flawed reasoning most similar to that in the consular chief's argument?
- A.Either the post hires more local staff or it ends weekend services, so if it hires no one it must end its weekend services
- B.The driver who reported the scheduling problem is often late himself, so his report about the problem can safely be ignored by the section
- C.The new cafeteria opened in March and staff sick days fell in April, so the cafeteria must have made the staff healthier
- D.Most guests who chose to leave a note at the comment table wrote that the music was too loud, so most guests disliked the music✓ Answer
People who choose to write to an inbox, like guests who choose to leave a note, are a self-selected group more likely to have complaints, so neither group represents the whole population. The cafeteria argument treats timing as cause, the driver argument attacks the person instead of the report, and the staffing argument is a false dilemma.
Ref QB-ATWNFMSource: Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Fallacies: Unrepresentative Sample (Biased Sample)Report a problem with this question
23. A budget officer at a hypothetical embassy argues: 'Either we cancel this year's national day reception or we overspend the representation budget. We cannot overspend the budget. So we must cancel the reception.' Yet a smaller reception or a co-sponsored one might also be possible. Which one contains a pattern of flawed reasoning most similar to that in the budget officer's argument?
- A.Either the section closes on Fridays or it never clears its backlog. A backlog is unacceptable, so the section must close on Fridays✓ Answer
- B.Every officer on the drafting team writes quickly, so the drafting team as a whole will produce its report quickly
- C.If staff complete the security briefing, they receive a badge. Lee received a badge, so Lee must have completed the security briefing
- D.The last two delegations that visited the embassy arrived late, so the delegation visiting next week will arrive late too
The original presents two options as the only ones, rejects one, and accepts the other, ignoring alternatives such as a smaller event. The Friday-closing argument does the same, ignoring options like overtime or extra staff. The badge argument affirms the consequent, the drafting-team argument moves from parts to the whole, and the delegation argument generalizes from two cases.
Ref QB-SARGVKSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.5 Informal Fallacies: false dichotomy (false dilemma)Report a problem with this question
24. A health unit nurse at a hypothetical embassy notes that employees who regularly use the embassy gym take fewer sick days than employees who do not. She concludes that using the gym reduces the number of sick days employees take. Which one contains a pattern of flawed reasoning most similar to that in the nurse's argument?
- A.Sections that hold weekly staff meetings miss fewer deadlines than others, so weekly meetings must prevent missed deadlines✓ Answer
- B.No one has ever shown that the protocol office mishandled an invitation, so the protocol office has never mishandled one
- C.If a cable is classified, it must be stored in the vault. This cable is in the vault, so this cable must be classified
- D.Every component of the new phone system passed its tests, so the phone system as a whole will work without any problems once installed
The nurse infers causation from a correlation between two groups, ignoring that healthier people may simply be more likely to use the gym. The weekly-meetings argument has the same flaw: better-organized sections may both hold meetings and meet deadlines. The phone-system argument reasons from parts to whole, the protocol argument treats absence of evidence as evidence of absence, and the cable argument affirms the consequent.
Ref QB-7TUNXGSource: OpenStax, Introduction to Philosophy, 5.5 Informal Fallacies: false cause (correlation does not equal causation)Report a problem with this question
25. A political counselor at a hypothetical embassy argues that the delegation being sent to a regional conference will negotiate effectively as a group, because each of its five members is an experienced and skilled negotiator when working alone. Which one contains a pattern of flawed reasoning most similar to that in the political counselor's argument?
- A.No one has proved that the new filing system saves time, so the new filing system must not save any time at all
- B.Each musician hired for the embassy concert is an excellent soloist, so together they will form an excellent ensemble✓ Answer
- C.The embassy as a whole met its annual energy target, so each section in the embassy must have met its own energy target
- D.The visa backlog grew after the new director arrived, so the new director must be responsible for the larger backlog
The counselor assumes that what is true of each member individually is true of the group, the fallacy of composition: skilled individuals may still work poorly together. The musicians argument makes the same part-to-whole move. The energy-target argument runs the opposite way, from whole to parts (division); the backlog argument treats sequence as cause; and the filing argument treats lack of proof as disproof.
Ref QB-PAPGCGSource: Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Fallacies: Composition and DivisionReport a problem with this question
Other topics in this exam
Original practice questions written to the three parts of the Foreign Service Officer Test as the U.S. Department of State describes them after the October 2025 revision. Not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. Department of State, and not real FSOT questions. Official FSOT practice test →