Chapters0/25 ▾
Chapter 5 · Lesson 3 of 5
Competence, written advice and return positions
1 min read
Section 10.35 makes competence a binding duty: the knowledge, skill, thoroughness and preparation the engagement requires. A practitioner can become competent by studying the area or by working with someone who already is. Section 10.33, by contrast, lists best practices for tax advisors that are aspirational and not a basis for discipline by themselves.
Section 10.37 governs written advice: use reasonable efforts to find the facts, do not rely on unreasonable assumptions or representations, and never factor in the chance that the return will not be audited or the issue not raised.
For return positions, section 10.34(a) ties into the preparer penalty under IRC section 6694(a). A position is not unreasonable if it has substantial authority, or if it has a reasonable basis and is adequately disclosed. Tax shelters and reportable transactions need more: a reasonable belief that the position is more likely than not correct.
Section 6694(b) is the larger penalty for willful or reckless conduct, reduced by any 6694(a) penalty for the same return, and the reasonable cause defense does not apply to it. Under section 10.34(d), a practitioner may rely in good faith on client information but must make reasonable inquiries when it looks incorrect, inconsistent or incomplete.
Check yourself
1. An enrolled agent concludes that a position a client wants to take has a reasonable basis but does not rise to substantial authority. Under Circular 230 and the preparer penalty rules, how may the practitioner properly sign the return?
2. Which of the following is a mandatory duty enforceable by sanction, rather than an aspirational best practice for tax advisors?
Facts checked 2026-11-15 · Sources: Treasury Department Circular No. 230 (31 CFR Part 10), IRS Publication 1345: Handbook for Authorized IRS e-file Providers, IRS: Enrolled Agents Frequently Asked Questions
Enrolled Agent (SEE) cheat sheet: every key fact on one page →